Understanding the Impact of Parental Swearing on Children
Written on
Chapter 1: The Reality of Swearing as a Parent
As a parent who frequently uses colorful language, I have come to embrace my tendency to swear. Interestingly, my use of profanity increased after having children, despite the common belief that parents should refrain from such language around their kids. While society often deems swearing in front of children as inappropriate, the reality is that parenting can be incredibly frustrating, and sometimes, a well-placed expletive feels necessary.
Swearing has its benefits. Research suggests that certain words, deemed offensive, serve a significant purpose in our communication. For instance, when faced with intense pain—whether from an injury or stepping on a Lego—shouting something like "oh, geez!" lacks the same cathartic release as a more potent exclamation like "fucking hell!"
A study conducted in 2009 by psychologist Richard Stephens from Keele University examined how swearing affects pain tolerance. Participants submerged their hands in ice-cold water and were allowed to either recite a neutral phrase or let loose with swears. The findings revealed that those who swore could endure the cold for an impressive 40 seconds longer than those who maintained a more polite demeanor.
This phenomenon is related to what scientists call the hypoalgesic effect. Although not completely understood, the theory suggests that swearing triggers a response in the brain, activating the amygdala and releasing adrenaline, which temporarily alleviates pain. However, moderation is key; excessive swearing can diminish its pain-relieving benefits.
Should Kids Be Allowed To Swear? - This video dives into whether children should be exposed to swearing and the potential effects it has on their development.
Section 1.1: The Misconception of Fragility in Children
It's a common misconception that children are fragile beings who need to be shielded from the realities of adult life, including swearing. While children certainly deserve love and protection, isolating them from real-world experiences—like hearing parents express frustration—does not prepare them for the complexities of life.
Societal norms dictate that profanity and children should not coexist, and some laws reflect this misguided belief. For example, in 2014, a South Carolina mother was arrested for swearing in a grocery store while arguing with her husband. The incident illustrates how societal judgment can lead to excessive consequences, potentially causing more harm than the swearing itself.
Philip Goodin, a language expert, emphasizes that the offense taken at swear words often stems from a societal readiness to be offended. He recounts an incident involving the playwright George Bernard Shaw, whose use of the word "bloody" in the early 20th century elicited uproarious reactions from audiences, highlighting the cultural weight of certain words.
Behavior Decoded: The Unexpected Reason Behind Your Child's Swearing - This video features a child psychologist discussing the reasons behind children's use of profanity and its implications.
Section 1.2: Swearing's Effects on Children
In a 2017 Op-Ed for the LA Times, cognitive scientist Benjamin Bergen argued against the notion that swearing around children is harmful. He points out that while the American Academy of Pediatrics claims that profanity can promote aggression or dampen emotional responses, there is no empirical evidence supporting these assertions. Moreover, conducting studies on young children would be ethically problematic.
Bergen's insights from college students suggest that everyday swearing has little effect on children, but the use of slurs can be damaging. A 2014 study found that exposure to derogatory language could lead to feelings of anxiety and depression in adolescents. This highlights a crucial distinction: while casual swearing may not harm children, swearing rooted in hate or directed at them is entirely different.
In summary, it's acceptable to let a few expletives slip in front of your kids. As long as the swearing is not laced with malice or directed at anyone, you're simply navigating the challenges of parenthood like any other average parent.