Exploring the Dangers and Delusions of Commercial Space Travel
Written on
Chapter 1: The Promise and Peril of Space Tourism
In light of SpaceX's groundbreaking Inspiration4 mission, which marked the first time an all-civilian crew orbited Earth, the prospects for commercial space tourism appear bright. However, history suggests a more cautious outlook.
It’s clear that the complexities and dangers of space travel have led to significant hesitations. NASA suspended its own spaceflight initiatives in the mid-1980s, banning private commercial flights until the early 2000s. This decision stemmed from the recognition that space travel is not only technically challenging but also perilous for human beings. These challenges persist today, despite advancements in technology.
For a deeper understanding of the inherent risks involved in civilian spaceflight, one can refer to my earlier article, "5 Reasons Why Commercial Space Tourism is a Long-Term Mission Fail." Here, I delve into the considerable dangers that overshadow the fleeting joys of space travel.
SpaceX recently faced regulatory hurdles that could jeopardize its ambitious plans. The video discusses the impact of FAA bureaucracy on Starship's future and the broader implications for commercial spaceflight.
Section 1.1: What Are the Benefits?
A key inquiry for advocates of commercial space tourism is: What tangible benefits does private space travel offer to society? The answer is minimal when compared to the extensive knowledge NASA has gained through its missions in low Earth orbit, as well as insights from other international space agencies, such as the European Space Agency.
Extensive research conducted by NASA has already illuminated the dangers of space travel to human health. For instance, astronaut Scott Kelly’s year-long stay aboard the International Space Station (ISS) resulted in groundbreaking studies comparing his biological responses to those of his identical twin, Mark Kelly, who remained on Earth.
The findings pointed to significant negative health impacts, including muscle loss, bone decalcification, heart strain, and alterations to the immune system. Time.com summarized these issues, emphasizing the profound risks space travel poses to human health and the pressing need for more research before contemplating long-term habitation on the Moon or Mars.
Section 1.2: The Threats of Space Debris
Beyond health concerns, safety issues related to near-Earth objects (NEOs) present another layer of risk. These include asteroids and comets that could pose catastrophic threats to space missions. According to NASA, over 1,000 NEOs have been cataloged, and the need for better detection and tracking of these objects is crucial.
Additionally, the growing problem of space junk—man-made debris orbiting the Earth—complicates the landscape. Astrophysicist Paul Sutter warns that there are over 20,000 tracked pieces of space debris that could threaten future missions.
Chapter 2: The Economic Divide
Commercial space tourism raises pressing questions about access. Ticket prices for these ventures often soar to astronomical heights, ranging from $250,000 to several million dollars, creating a stark divide between the wealthy and the general populace.
For example, Axiom Space charges up to $55 million for a week-long trip to the ISS, while Virgin Galactic's ticket prices could soon reach $500,000. This raises ethical concerns about who gets to experience space travel and who is left behind.
This video showcases SpaceX's launch of a civilian crew on a groundbreaking mission, highlighting both the excitement and the risks of space tourism.
Paying the Price
The socioeconomic divide is glaring. Those in financial hardship have little hope of participating in these excursions, often relying on luck for a chance to board a spacecraft.
In 2014, I spoke with Jim Adams, former NASA deputy chief technologist, who emphasized the practical benefits NASA's missions bring to Earth. NASA's Earth Science missions yield valuable data that can improve disaster response and climate monitoring, in stark contrast to the often superficial claims made by commercial space ventures.
Space Vacations: A Vision of the Future
Envision a future where space hotels float above Earth, promising luxury vacations but also potentially exposing guests to hazards. The prospect of space advertising and the commercialization of space raises questions about safety and regulation.
As proposals for such ventures emerge, it’s essential to consider the implications of autonomous technology in these environments. The fictional world of "2001: A Space Odyssey" serves as a cautionary tale about the unpredictability of technology in space.
Readers React
Feedback from my previous article revealed a widespread skepticism about commercial space tourism, with many arguing that it serves only the ultra-wealthy.
In conclusion, while Elon Musk’s vision of a multi-planetary species is admirable, we must critically assess whether commercial space tourism truly advances that goal or simply serves as a profit-driven venture. The risks involved warrant serious consideration, and as we move forward, prioritizing safety over profit should be paramount.
What are your thoughts on the future of commercial space tourism? How do its benefits and risks weigh against one another? Please share your insights in the comments below.